Regulation & ComplianceCredit rating agencies lack transparency, says ESMA

Credit rating agencies lack transparency, says ESMA

Surveillance of structured finance credit ratings is lacking at all four of Europe’s leading rating agencies, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has concluded after a year-long investigation.

Surveillance of structured finance credit ratings is lacking at all four of Europe’s leading rating agencies, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has concluded after a year-long investigation.

ESMA’s investigation, which ran from October 2013 until September 2014, focussed on the ratings agencies Fitch, Moody’s, DBRS and S&P. Between them, the four firms account for nearly all outstanding credit ratings on EU structured finance instruments.

It found evidence of shortcomings in the way that structured finance ratings were being monitored, as well as issues relating to methodology, disclosure and transparency. Concerns were also raised over annual internal reviews that lacked timely completion or independent oversight.

These weaknesses could affect the quality of the ratings and compromise the protections afforded to investors, said investigators.

All registered CRAs [Credit Ratings Agencies] should take note of the problems identified and ensure that they properly incorporate the requirements and objectives of the CRA Regulation into their working practices in order to ensure the quality of credit ratings and maintain investor confidence,” said Steven Maijoor, chair of the ESMA, who suggested that agencies use the best practice guidelines outlined in the report to help them improve.

The high volume of issued structured finance instruments and renewed interest in securitisation as an alternative funding source make the results of this review all the more timely,” he added.

ESMA has outlined remedial action plans for the agencies involved and will continue to monitor their improvement.

 

Related Articles

Which transaction monitoring software is right for my institution?

Regulation & Compliance Which transaction monitoring software is right for my institution?

4w Elaine Dorkham
Bringing cryptocurrency to the front line  

Payments Bringing cryptocurrency to the front line  

4m Karen Vickers
China’s regulatory changes stimulate international interest

Asia Pacific China’s regulatory changes stimulate international interest

5m Michael McCaw
Treasury TV: Yeng Butler compares US and European MMF reforms

Compliance Treasury TV: Yeng Butler compares US and European MMF reforms

5m Victoria Beckett
AccessPay offers free tool to help corporates utilise PSD2

Payments AccessPay offers free tool to help corporates utilise PSD2

5m GTNews
Many treasurers juggle increased GDPR burden with business restructuring

More News Many treasurers juggle increased GDPR burden with business restructuring

6m Victoria Beckett
The arrival of PSD2: views from the market

Banking The arrival of PSD2: views from the market

6m Victoria Beckett
PSD2: dull name, but seismic effect

Clearing & Settlement PSD2: dull name, but seismic effect

6m Alex Kwiatkowski