Corporate TreasuryHow Today’s Volatility Necessitates Scenario Modelling for Corporate Treasurers

How Today’s Volatility Necessitates Scenario Modelling for Corporate Treasurers

Amidst market uncertainty, businesses are urged to understand the importance of FX hedging and adopt alternative approaches beyond traditional banking. Corporate treasurers are increasingly managing FX risk, using tools like CFaR and EaR.

Facing some of the most profound uncertainty in modern history, corporate treasurers are being tested like never before in 2024.

Geopolitical dynamics have continued to inject volatility into the global economy. The interplay between geopolitical tensions and economic policies worldwide has been a critical factor influencing market behaviors and economic forecasts.

A significant focus has been on moderating inflation and the response of central banks across different regions. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) highlighted a projection of global growth at 3.1% for 2024, slightly up from previous forecasts, thanks to resilience in major economies and fiscal support in some regions.

However, this growth comes amidst challenges like elevated central bank policy rates aimed at fighting inflation, a withdrawal of fiscal support in the face of high debt, and low underlying productivity growth. Inflation rates are expected to fall, reflecting the unwinding of supply-side issues and the impact of restrictive monetary policies.

While the global economy shows signs of steady growth and a moderating inflation landscape, risks remain. Upside potentials include faster disinflation leading to eased financial conditions, while downside risks involve possible new commodity price spikes due to geopolitical shocks, persistent inflation, or deepening issues in specific sectors such as China’s property market.

The challenge for policymakers is managing the descent of inflation to target levels, calibrating monetary policy to inflation dynamics, and focusing on fiscal consolidation to prepare for future shocks.

For most corporate treasury teams, events unfold faster than strategies can adapt. Yet some are better positioned to ride the waves than others. The difference lies in detecting storm systems early and mapping out contingency plans ahead of time. In other words, scenario modelling and risk mitigation are the tools to navigate these unprecedented waters.

Quantifying Your Exposure

With volatility emerging across multiple fronts simultaneously, treasurers need to actively quantify their firm’s exposures. This requires running various scenarios through financial forecast models – estimating best and worst-case variants.

What happens to cash flows, debt covenants, foreign exchange balances and earnings if interest rates spike further? How would a commodity supply shock or resurgent pandemic impact operations? By stress testing the entire balance sheet, both downside risks and strategic opportunities become apparent.

For example, interest rate hikes directly impact variable rate loans and bonds. Scenario analysis allows treasurers to reforecast future interest expenses and debt servicing ability if rates were to rise 200, 300 or 500bps higher.

Similarly, earnings simulations can reveal how growth plans may stall if tighter financial conditions constrain customer purchasing power. Resources can shift from growth to financial risk management.

Hedging Your Bets

Once exposures are mapped and quantified, mitigation strategies can be evaluated. With exposures quantified, financial derivatives like swaps, forwards and options can protect/lock-in rates, currency levels, input prices etc.

There are myriad hedging tools available, though their effectiveness depends entirely on the underlying risks and market environments being addressed. Effectiveness simulations entail running the same exposure scenarios again but with hypothetical hedges in place. Treasurers can measure how much each hedge would cushion against downside scenarios.

This is where scenario models guide strategic decisions. By assessing hedge performance across multiple hypothetical scenarios, treasurers can zero in on appropriate instruments and lock them in when markets are favorable. An interest rate swap may successfully cap interest costs in a rising rate environment. Meanwhile currency options might prove unnecessary if FX fluctuations stay within expected ranges.

Making strategic hedging decisions informed by data rather than guesswork gives treasury teams the best chance of weathering volatility storms.

CFaR and EaR

CFaR (Cash Flow at Risk) and EaR (Earnings at Risk) are two key risk metrics that directly tie into the scenario modelling and analysis discussed:

Cash Flow at Risk (CFaR)

  • CFaR measures the maximum expected decrease in future cash flows under a severe but plausible downside scenario.
  • In scenario models, inputs like lower sales, higher input costs, FX swings, interest rate hikes etc. directly lower projected future cash flow.
  • The differential between the base case cash flow forecast and stressed scenario cash flow forecast represents the company’s CFaR exposure.

Earnings at Risk (EaR)

  • Similarly, EaR estimates the maximum potential hit to earnings based on unfavorable scenarios playing out.
  • Scenario assumptions that drive lower revenue, higher expenses, greater interest costs, etc. reduce forward-looking earnings in models.
  • The EaR metric quantifies by how much annual or quarterly EPS might sink under a severe downside scenario vs. the base case.

In essence, CFaR and EaR are output risk metrics derived from running stressed downside scenarios through financial forecast models. These metrics quantify exposures in terms of potential cash flow and earnings impacts.

Having visibility into CFaR and EaR then allows treasury teams to evaluate risk mitigation tradeoffs more deliberately. The metrics also facilitate risk monitoring by establishing exposure limits which if exceeded require hedging.

Steering Through the Storm

While each company’s risks are unique, the need for navigational tools is universal in these white water conditions. Corporate treasurers focused purely on rear view accounting data will inevitably struggle with sudden market swings.

But those who model various scenarios and implement precautionary hedges will maintain stable financial footing – no matter how stormy the seas get. With volatility likely to increase this year, scenario analyzers and risk managers will be best positioned for the ride.

Subscribe to get your daily business insights

Whitepapers & Resources

2021 Transaction Banking Services Survey

2021 Transaction Banking Services Survey

CGI Transaction Banking Survey 2020

CGI Transaction Banking Survey 2020

TIS Sanction Screening Survey Report

TIS Sanction Screening Survey Report

Enhancing your strategic position: Digitalization in Treasury

Enhancing your strategic position: Digitalization in Treasury

Netting: An Immersive Guide to Global Reconciliation

Netting: An Immersive Guide to Global Reconciliation